Thursday, March 24, 2011
Am I encouraging racism?
This past weekend was a big one for my host family. Lion's Canadian boss came to visit Jamaica and took all his Jamaican farmhands out on the western side of the island. I went to Falmouth with my host mom to celebrate my one year anniversary on the island with some other Peace Corps volunteers. When they both returned home, I overheard the comparison of their trips and resultant exposure to "how white people stay." The things that I heard filled my head with questions. I jotted down a few outstanding quotes. "Black people selfish. White people giving." "White people nice and loving, black people a sh*t." "These [white] people don't have money either but they still go out and see the place. White people interesting more than black people. They enjoy life more." "White people treat we better than black people."
Color stereotyping is rampant in Jamaica, especially in the country. Light skin means intelligence, beauty, and success. Darker skin is associated with laziness, ignorance, and crime. Good hair is straight and long. Bad hair is short and curly. Parents tell their children that they are black and ugly. Some men and women use laundry "cake soap" which contains bleach to lighten their skin. Many women weave extensions into their hair or cream their hair to make it straight. African Americans deal with these same issues especially in urban areas, and many sociologists say that these attitudes stem from colonialism and slavery. However, this was different. Adults were justifying their intangible racist ideas with me as a real life example. When I tried to argue that color had nothing to do with it my host mom scoffed and reproachfully told me that black people are worthless. How can someone live forty-four years and think that about themselves?
Children's voices carry the most fundamental ideas of a culture. The children often tell me that I'm not like other adults or teachers. I play with them, give them attention, and don't beat them. To them, those qualities are inextricably linked to the fact that I'm white and have "pretty tall hair." My neighbors and community leaders tell me they need more white people in their country to make it a better place. I find myself wishing I could perm my hair, dye my skin brown, and prove that personal qualities and color are not related. Maybe shaving my head would show the young girls that you don't have to have long hair to be pretty or nice or respectful.
Interestingly, I have encountered the opposite attitude amongst wealthier and better educated Jamaicans. This is a hopeful sign that changes are beginning, but these changes are still nascent in Jamaica.
Color stereotyping is rampant in Jamaica, especially in the country. Light skin means intelligence, beauty, and success. Darker skin is associated with laziness, ignorance, and crime. Good hair is straight and long. Bad hair is short and curly. Parents tell their children that they are black and ugly. Some men and women use laundry "cake soap" which contains bleach to lighten their skin. Many women weave extensions into their hair or cream their hair to make it straight. African Americans deal with these same issues especially in urban areas, and many sociologists say that these attitudes stem from colonialism and slavery. However, this was different. Adults were justifying their intangible racist ideas with me as a real life example. When I tried to argue that color had nothing to do with it my host mom scoffed and reproachfully told me that black people are worthless. How can someone live forty-four years and think that about themselves?
Children's voices carry the most fundamental ideas of a culture. The children often tell me that I'm not like other adults or teachers. I play with them, give them attention, and don't beat them. To them, those qualities are inextricably linked to the fact that I'm white and have "pretty tall hair." My neighbors and community leaders tell me they need more white people in their country to make it a better place. I find myself wishing I could perm my hair, dye my skin brown, and prove that personal qualities and color are not related. Maybe shaving my head would show the young girls that you don't have to have long hair to be pretty or nice or respectful.
Interestingly, I have encountered the opposite attitude amongst wealthier and better educated Jamaicans. This is a hopeful sign that changes are beginning, but these changes are still nascent in Jamaica.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This is a great post and something that I have pondered and worried about. I am only a nominee and awaiting an invitation but as a Women's Studies/ Sociology student I have studied racial relations and body image across cultural boundaries. It really is difficult to try and change the opinions of others since they are so deeply enrooted in their social construction. My suggestion is to perhaps set up a discussion group or just informally talking to the young girls about beauty and body image and acceptance of themselves :)
ReplyDeleteHi Liz! How interested. I've read your blog and I found it to be thoughtful. Being a real Jamaican I'm proud of myself being black and beautiful. I would say this to every other Jamaican ladies who think of themselves as lazy, ignorant and not intelligent. Be more positive of themselves, develop good self-esteem, and believe in themselves. The colour of the skin and the length of the hair had nothing to do with the beauty inside.
ReplyDeleteI was with you guys in Falmouth and it was so amazing. I enjoy myself a lot because I felt that I was with a group of people that make me feel so natural. The way I used to think about tourists, that they are proud, all dressed up and selfish, I was completely wrong. I realize that you all were down to earth, don't even care about the way you guys dress, so friendly. That tells me a whole lot. It was a wonderful experience and make me feel more positive about myself.
I love the way you think about yourself and about others. You have not seen yourself better than anybody else. You don't have to change the colour of your skin or the colour of your hair to prove anything because you have already said a lot and being around you what I've seen tells everything. Keep up the good work! I would love to spend more times with you. When will that be?
[with computer help from Bart ;)]
Hi Crystal, great idea! Where are you nominated to?
ReplyDeleteHi Rose, Thanks so much for sharing that with me. I'm happy you have such a healthy and positive self-image and relieved to hear that spending time with whiteys enhances it! Hopefully we'll get to see each other again soon.